Skip to main content

Mistakes to Avoid if You Own Rental Properties


Are you new to the rental property scene? Learn what mistakes to avoid so you can have a prosperous real estate investment with less stress—and more money.
Rental properties can be an excellent investment, however, you have to be sure you are on top of your game as an owner and landlord. Otherwise, you could be dealing with tenants who disturb others, don't pay rent, or leave you with a damaged rental unit (and a hefty bill) when they leave.

There are disadvantages to every situation, but don't let that prevent you from getting into the real estate investment game. You just need to know how to protect yourself and your rental property. Here are five major mistakes to avoid when you own and rent a home (or even just a room), so you can focus on making money—not pouring more money into a poorly managed investment.

Not following through with background checks.

One of the most important things you can do as a landlord is to run background checks on potential tenants. This can ensure you are finding the best tenant for your rental unit. Background checks can help you search for any red flags and help you verify things such as the applicant's identity, credit history, employment, etc. 

Forgetting to check proof of income.

The last thing you want to do is rent to someone who can't afford the monthly payments. Remember: The truth is in the numbers. Think of it as a bank would when reviewing POI—according to Investopedia, most lenders allow a maximum of 28 percent expense-to-income ratio for housing. So, if the applicant earns $2,000 a month, their housing cost should not exceed $560 a month.

There are a variety of ways to verify proof of income. Some applicants may supply pay stubs, tax returns, or bank statements. Make sure their proof of income is current and verify with the employer by phone to ensure they are still employed. Not verifying proof of income can be a costly mistake.

Skipping the essential lease details.

You can say anything you want as far as the rules of your rental unit go, but if you don't specify something within the lease, you can't enforce it later. That's why inputting details in the lease, such as "quiet hours," no smoking, no pets, etc., is critical. A lease is a binding legal document, and if either party doesn't uphold the agreement, that lease can be terminated.

Don't forget to specify the renewal terms as well. For instance, does the lease automatically renew for the same terms, and if so, how far in advance do you require notification of the tenant moving? This clause is applied to you as a landlord as well; if you decide not to renew the lease, then the tenant needs an allotted amount of time to move out. The lease should also mention any late fees, eviction clauses, and details about the deposit. Be as specific as possible.

Not checking the previous rental references.

Sure, your applicant seems like they would be an excellent fit for your place; however, you don't truly know someone until you have them living with you or in your unit. So be sure to require previous rental references on the application that you can contact. These should only be landlords that the tenant previously rented from, not general character references.

You can ask the reference relevant questions, such as whether the tenant paid their rent on time, left the apartment or house damaged, or gave proper notice to vacate. This knowledge can help you weed out unreliable applicants so you can rent to someone responsible. Of course, sometimes unforeseen things happen, but this will help you determine whether an issue is likely a one-time thing or repetitive behavior.

Renting to friends or family without a lease.

Blood may be thicker than water, but it's not thicker than money. When it comes to renting to friends and family, you still need to follow the same protocols as you would with someone you don't know. Unfortunately, if you don't, you could get seriously taken advantage of.

So unless you can afford to house your relatives for free, be sure to write up a lease just like you would with any other applicant. Before renting to a family member or friend, you should first consider whether it's worth risking the relationship—similar to deciding whether to loan a loved one money. What could this do to your relationship if the transaction doesn't work out well?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

GTA REALTORS ® Release July 2025 Stats

TORONTO, ONTARIO, August 6, 2025 – The Greater Toronto Area (GTA) experienced the best home sales result for the month of July since 2021. Sales were also up relative to listings, suggesting a modest tightening in the market compared to last year.  “Improved affordability, brought about by lower home prices and borrowing costs, is starting to translate into increased home sales. More relief is required, particularly where borrowing costs are concerned, but it’s clear that a growing number of households are finding affordable options for homeownership,” said Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) President Elechia Barry-Sproule. GTA REALTORS® reported 6,100 home sales through TRREB’s MLS® System in July 2025 – up by 10.9 per cent compared to July 2024. New listings entered into the MLS® System totalled 17,613 – up by 5.7 per cent year-over year.  On a seasonally adjusted basis, July home sales increased month-over-month compared to June 2025. New listings also rose compared...

GTA REALTORS Release April 2025 Stats

April home sales followed the regular seasonal trend with an increase relative to March. However, total residential transactions in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) were down compared to the same time last year, as potential buyers continue to wait for lower borrowing costs and for certainty about the trajectory of the economy. “Following the recent federal election, many households across the GTA are closely monitoring the evolution of our trade relationship with the United States. If this relationship moves in a positive direction, we could see an uptick in transactions driven by improved consumer confidence and a market that is both more affordable and better supplied,” said TRREB President Elechia Barry-Sproule. GTA REALTORS® reported 5,601 home sales through TRREB’s MLS® System in April 2025 – down by 23.3 per cent compared to April 2024. New listings in the MLS® System amounted to 18,836– up by 8.1 per cent year-over-year. On a seasonally adjusted basis, April home sales edged up m...

Getting Your Home Back To School Ready

The countdown is on for back to school. If you have school-aged kids, now the time to prep for the busy days ahead. So, how can you get your home ready for the rush? Organize your entryway with a place to hang jackets and a spot for essentials you might need just before you go (e.g., sunglasses and keys). Declutter clothes and books, donating or selling items your kids have outgrown. Designate a study area with ample space, good lighting, and a comfortable chair. This could be in the kitchen so you can supervise homework while cooking, at the dining table, or at a desk in your child’s bedroom. Also, organize and stock up on school supplies. Organize cupboard space for lunch containers. Create a spot for quick and healthy after-school snacks like fruits and nuts, and reserve space in the fridge for perishable snacks like yogurt, cheese, and cut-up vegetables. Have a spot to hang art and test scores, such as a pegboard, a strong with clothespin, or a classic spot, the fridge. With little...